Ratings: The The American Idol Show Show Falls, But Nevertheless Wins Survivor Hits Series Low

When does frozen mousse trump perfectly cooked halibut? When you're on top Chef! Despite her nearly inedible, ice-hard confection, Sarah - having a couple of major backing from Tom Colicchio - handled to obtain for the finale with Paul over her friend Lindsay Autry, whose error-free, although less creative, dish sent her packing. "In my opinion they were really nitpicking in those days plus it came lower to doing something harmful like what she did against me being great, while not harmful enough," Lindsay notifies TVGuide.com. "I realize I didn't make any mistakes, however guess they preferred to determine more." Was she surprised that her well-made dish lost to such shoddy execution? Uncover below. Discover More > Other Links From TVGuide.com Tom ColicchioTop ChefGail SimmonsPadma LakshmiBeverly KimEdward LeeGrayson SchmitzLindsay AutryNyesha ArringtonPaul QuiSarah Grueneberg